Submit Your Comments
hqLg4l

"We trust that you will avoid using harsh language and will refrain from making unsubstantiated allegations against individuals and firms. Your constructive feedback and opinions are very valuable to all of us in the industry. "

Comments Posted
Mukund Surana ARN NO :ARN-69732 Alwar, 26 Apr 2013

Good Presenatation for clients to convince. This help us

NIMAY CHARAN RAKSHIT ARN NO :29984 ROURKELA, 16 Feb 2013

THANKS TO GUIDE ME ON RIGHT TIME WITH ELSS FUND.AND ENCOURAGE.

c.g. daware ARN NO :arn- 22804 akola, 15 Dec 2012

tnx for yr valued information and giving a good guidance

ANIL PARIKH ARN NO :ARN-0492 PUNE, 13 Dec 2012

GOOD STASTITICS

HN SUBRAMANIAN ARN NO :479786 chennai, 11 Dec 2012

Excellent work... Thank You Very much for your Value information and Keep posted any other Innovative presentations comparisons to bring more investors into wealth creation. Thank You..

manjusha shrivastava ARN NO :81193 bhopal, 10 Dec 2012

very good

YAMPARALA JAYAKRISHNA ARN NO :39569 CHILAKALURIPET, 08 Dec 2012

Excellent work... Thank You Very much for your Value added information, Keep posted any other Innovative presentations comparisons to bring more investors into wealth creation. Thank You..

YOGESH SHAH ARN NO :36492 mumbai, 06 Dec 2012

very good observation & hard work by mr amit jain. thanks mr amit jain for his contribution.

v.ravi ARN NO :17544 warangal, 06 Dec 2012

well it is verygood statement elss vs ppf/nsc. public definatly get more income investing elss funds.

dharmendra gupta ARN NO :78615 allahabad, 05 Dec 2012

ELSS are the best instuments for 80cin india.

Chetan ARN NO :27339 jaipur, 05 Dec 2012

Yes I think i will be able to use this to pitch ELSS more effectively with our clients.I believe ELSS funds are better long term wealth creators as compared to all other tax savers . Thanks !!! for sheared this details with u.

Pawan Agrawal ARN NO :25741 New Delhi, 05 Dec 2012

very well articulated Amit. thanks for insight.

sandeep kimti ARN NO :62633 mandsaur, 05 Dec 2012

WELL DONE SIR. Bank Fd & NSC ELSS & PPF ELSS is more tax efficient

Amol Chitale ARN NO :30587 Solapur, 05 Dec 2012

Nice work Mr.Amit. I also have a personal word of CAUTION to all fellow Advisors.NEVER ask your client to put money in a single ELSS,i.e invest their money in at least 2-3 funds.I LOST clients because of relying too much on Birla Tax 96.It has been the WORST performer. In 2005-06 this fund was the top performer !?

Ilyas ARN NO :6721 Udaipur, 05 Dec 2012

AH! The proof of the pudding!! Well done Amitji. Keep up the good work. Best wishes.

kamlesh sahijwani ARN NO :4875 jaipur, 05 Dec 2012

Really fantastic hard worked by Amitji.This will open eyes of investors,if investor is serious about his money & has time for 5 years.

Rahul Ranjan ARN NO :24262 NEW DELHI, 04 Dec 2012

Dear Amit Jee, I my life I have trained many IFA, NDs, Banks and Corporates. For me you are the most practical and innovative student I have ever seen in my life. The biggest asset you have - You try to help others all the time. All the best for your life. Regards, Rahul Ranjan, CFP, Financial Trainer.

GAUTAM RATHORE ARN NO :ARN-9156 UDAIPUR, 04 Dec 2012

Dear Amit ji good comparision. Bank Fd & NSC ELSS & PPF ELSS is more tax efficient.but Investor not continue invested in Tax Plan otherwise get good retrun, Good Job Lage raho mere bhai

Ashish Modani ARN NO :23800 Jaipur, 04 Dec 2012

Amit ji, I have known you as a person who is very innovative and hard worker and you have proved here. hats off to you for such a wonderful analysis. would hope that you come with such useful and wonderful tools more often. thanks once again

Ln sirigineedi Nageswara rao ARN NO :27088 ELURU, 04 Dec 2012

very useful tool to IFA community presented by Amit. Thanks for sharing.

vikas hore ARN NO :37781 nagpur, 04 Dec 2012

thanks & excellant working . ELSS more effictively if you work 15 year period elss return 3 to 4 times of ppf.

RAJESH SHARMA ARN NO :1334 jaipur, 04 Dec 2012

xcllent job done by Amit.this is the time when we all needs such tools

Haseen Ansari ARN NO :ARN-32305 Varanasi, 04 Dec 2012

Very Good tool for ELSS VS. FD & PPF.Thanks alot

Srinivas Rao Kasinathuni ARN NO :11460 VIJAYAWADA, 04 Dec 2012

Excellent analytical job. Any hard-core anti-elss guy would find it to refute this evidence. What better armoury any willing advisor would require than this to emerge victorious this tax season? Only when we advisors do such independent research will we be able to make inroads into the traditional tax saving products terrain. Thanks to his generosity in sharing such data with all of us. There are even better performing schemes for the same period and we could all do our own bit and prepare such charts for those schemes!!

RAJNIKANT JAJU ARN NO :15648 AMRAVATI, 04 Dec 2012

AMITJI, THANKS FOR SHARING YOUR RESEARCH TO INVEST IN EQUITY SCHEMES (ELSS) RATHER THAN TRADITIONAL SCHEMES (PPF,FD)

guruprasad ARN NO :60291 bangalore, 04 Dec 2012

well done amitji, good information to be used for all of us. since the comparison is with bank fd and nsc/ppf probably amitji has restricted the period to five years but for longer duration, with this data people can visualize the return, well it is true that savings is for a life time . can mr nandakishor share his adopted strategy which is quite thought provoking and time consuming and it is working quite well with his clients,for the benefit for all IFAs !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Dharamvir Singh ARN NO :53786 New Delhi, 04 Dec 2012

very good presentation Amit Ji. we will inspire and do well.

PRABHA MALHOTRA ARN NO :7999 JABALPUR, 04 Dec 2012

WEEL AMIT. IFA COMMUNITY IS PROUD TO HAVE COMMITTED IFAS LIKE U WHO BELIEVE IN THE EQUITY WELL DONE KEEP UP THE SPIRIT

anuradha srinivasan ARN NO :4119 Tiruvarur, 04 Dec 2012

Well done Amit thanks to share with us

Gimesh V. Dholakia ARN NO :53595 Mumbai, 03 Dec 2012

Dear Amitji, Very nice presentation and analysis. This will really help IFAs to get client gain confidence in Equity schemes and invest them regularly even in lumpsum besides SIP. Thank you so much to share your valuable innovative strategy.

BARANWAL ASSOCIATES ARN NO :77448 VARANASI, 03 Dec 2012

WELL DONE,AMIT-------------CONGRATE FOR GREAT JOB DONE FOR ELSS V/S PPF,BANK F.D. ETC COMPARISION.A GREATTOOLS FOR CURRENT MUTUAL FUND INDUSTRY.------------PRITHVI RAJ BARANWAL

K.B.JAIN ARN NO :46470 MUMBAI, 03 Dec 2012

A POSITIVE CALCULATION TOWARDS BRINGING CLIENT TO ELSS SCHEME

CHILUKURI K R L RAO ARN NO :70974 HYDERABAD, 03 Dec 2012

Mr.Amit jain, I appreciate the positiveness with which you shared such a useful data with all of us. Dissemination of quality data such as this would increase knowledge levels of adviser community as a whole and increases the respect for the community. Thank you wealthforum. Wish you bring in plenty more such data.

Mukesh ARN NO :ARN-42423 Rajkot, 03 Dec 2012

thanks to share with us

kamini sahu ARN NO :78012 bhilai, 03 Dec 2012

client ka dimag khole ga.

mayank sheth ARN NO :9834 ahmedabad, 03 Dec 2012

amitji thanks for sharing good idea

shah pavan manikchand ARN NO :8001 PANDHARPUR, 03 Dec 2012

AMITJI YOUR PLANNING WAS NICE & QUIT FOR SOME INVESTORS I THINK PPF & LIKE OTHER PRODUCT IS ALSO NICE BECAUSE INT TAXFREE,EXEMPT FORM WEALTH TAX ALSO NO COURT ATTACMENT & THERE WAS SOME LIMT TO INVEST ELLS etc. HENCE YOU MAY GIVE OPTION BEFORE CLIENT/INVESTOR TO CONSIDER ALL FACTS & CIRCUMSTANCES & GIVE CHOICE INVESTOR

dvlsvprasad ARN NO :62398 ongole, 03 Dec 2012

excellent veryusefull to ifa in smallertowns likeme thanq somuch

anil sahu ARN NO :68581 itarsi, 03 Dec 2012

its a brilient analisys , thanks to share with us Anil sahu

Atul Mukhi ARN NO :1773 New Delhi, 03 Dec 2012

a very nice and convincing case made for investing in ELSS and equity at large....kudos to Mr Amit Jain for such a nice article and sharing it with all, such sharing if done regularly amongst all of the IFA community shall help in saving them from the crisis they are facing, i feel all IFAs should take the cue from Amit and share their innovative ideas so that all can benefit from it and prosper.

UJJAWAL CHADHA ARN NO :2138 new delhi, 03 Dec 2012

Dear Amit, Your data is a great advantage to investors,financial distributors and even mutual funds. This is a good tool to explain it to the clients. But still can it be taken as thumb rule.

T S RAWAT ARN NO :15427 DEHRADUN, 03 Dec 2012

veri gud & nice

B.Ch.SWAMY ARN NO :73552 SALUR, 03 Dec 2012

Amit, nice planning, it should be impact over the clients. Good. Keep it up.

Nanda Kishore ARN NO :23971 Bangalore, 03 Dec 2012

The statastics shared is quite clear. But is it that we r all gunning for an investment horizon of only 5 years or investment an exercise which has to run as far as an individual is earning or probably as far as one is dealing with money. If the later is true, can anybody think of a strategy which is fool proof for one and all. I have adopted one such strategy which is quite thought provoking and time consuming and it is working quite well with my clients.

Stephen Noel DSouza ARN NO :ARN-1221 Pune, 03 Dec 2012

Excellent job Amit - keep up the great research. Although comparing ELSS with PPF is like comparing Apples with Oranges - two different Asset Allocation categories - it may convince those only looking at the aspect of returns.

PRADIPTA KUMAR PATNAIK ARN NO :63934 BERHAMPUR, ODISHA, 03 Dec 2012

Thank for sharing.

harish agrawal ARN NO :1814 indore, 03 Dec 2012

very good return chart thanks

hiren mehta ARN NO :3427 mumbai, 03 Dec 2012

A very good comparision. Bank Fd & NSC are taxable while ELSS & PPF are tax free..... So ELSS is more tax efficient.

N S Shah ARN NO :2328 Ahmedabad, 03 Dec 2012

Very Good primary preparation by Mr. Amit. Supporting data always helps in justification for a product. Selling is not important. A suitable product in the portfolio of investor is ultimate success. Congrats.

Dhiraj Mittal ARN NO :7493 New Delhi, 03 Dec 2012

Good job Amit....thanks for sharing your innovative strategies. You should write more often for wealth forum.